tion, that the U. S. Commissioner of Education be respectfully requested to procure legislation from Congress permanently appropriating a sum of money for the education of the children of Alaska without distinction of race.

The present method of supporting the schools of Alaska by an annual appropriation from Congress is very unsatisfactory. As Congress one year voted $25,000 and the second nothing and the third $15,000, it can readily be seen that neither the school board nor the teachers can arrange for the schools until after Congressional action has been taken, nor until such action is had can they be sure that there will be any schools. And not only that, but some years the action of Congress is not known in Alaska until three months after the fiscal school year commences. A failure on the part of Congress any one year to make the necessary appropriation would close the schools, scatter Government property, and throw the teachers out of employment thousands of miles away from home and friends.

The disadvantages of the present system need but to be stated to be seen.

In the Western States and Territories the general land laws of the country provide that sections 16 and 36 in each township be set apart for the use of the schools in said States and Territories. In some of the States this has been a munificent endowment.

But Alaska has no townships and no surveyed lands and no law by which they can be surveyed. And when in course of time the general land laws are extended over it, the nature of the country and the peculiar climate and the requirements of the population will prevent to any great extent the laying out of the land in sections of a mile square. Thus while no school fund is practicable for years to come from the lands, the General Government derives a regular revenue from the seal islands and other sources, a portion of which could be used in the place of the proceeds of the sale of school lands. 4. An obligatory attendance law. -The operation of the obligatory attendance law which was enacted by the Territorial board of education and approved by the honorable the Secretary of the Interior in 1887, has been recently suspended by order of the United States Commissioner of Education.

In view of the importance of some suitable law for securing the more regular attendance at school of the children of Alaska, the Territorial board of education at its semiannual meeting June 14-19 took the following action:

"Whereas it is the invariable experience of all who have been engaged or interested for years in the difficult task of attempting to educate and civilize the natives and creoles of Alaska that the greatest obstacles to success are, first, the want of adequate means of securing the regular and general attendance of the children of these people at the various Government schools and, second, the stolid indifference, superstition, and fear of change on the part of the greater number of the parents of such children; and

"Whereas 'experience has also demonstrated that wherever native policemen have been employed and paid heretofore a moderate compensation for gathering these children into the school rooms and thus compelling attendance, not only is the average attendance itself largely increased, but an interest in the progress of the pupils and the success of the schools themselves has been gradually and permanently created in those native and creole parents; and

"Whereas, the Government of the United States is annually appropriating large sums of money for the purpose of educating and civilizing these people and employing competent and zealous teachers for that purpose, who are making great sacrifices by enduring severe privations, general discomfort, and personal isolation among an alien and barbarous race of people: Therefore,

Be it resolved by the Territorial board of education, That the Hon. Lyman E. Knapp, the governor of the District of Alaska, is hereby requested and urged to embody in his forthcoming annual report to the Department of the Interior the suggestions we have made herein, with the recommendation that Congress take the subject of compulsory education of the natives and creoles of Alaska into consideration, and, in addition to making the usual appropriations for the schools of the District, add thereto such enactments as will compel the regular attendance of the pupils at such schools as are already established or may be hereafter provided."

I renew my recommendations of former reports on this subject.

5. School police.-With the granting of an obligatory attendance law, and even without it, the appointment of a native policeman in the native villages where schools exist, whose duty shall be to see that the children are in school, will greatly increase the present attendance.

I therefore recommend that an allowance of ten or fifteen dollars per month be allowed from the school fund for the employment of such men.

6. I recommend, that the honorable the Secretary of the Interior be respectfully requested to ask Congress for an appropriation of $75,000 for education in Alaska for the year ending June 30, 1891.

7. In 1887-88 the Territorial board of education recommended to the United States

Commissioner of Education that the salary of the general agent of education be increased to $2,400 annually.

As nothing was done, I respectfully ask the board to renew the request.

In closing this report I can not permit to pass unchallenged the statement made by the president of the Territorial board of education, which appears on page 181 of the Annual Report of the Commissioner of Education, 1887-88, that my annual report for 1887-88 was recalled by the board of education in Alaska because of " a number of material inaccuracies in the report." My report for that year was regularly indorsed and approved by the board, ex-Governor Swineford not being present, on September 15, 1888, and forwarded to the Commissioner of Education.

At a meeting of the board on October 31, 1888, four members being present, Mr. Swine ford delivered a tirade against the general agent of education, claiming that some of the statements of the annual report were false and demanding that the vote of approval be reconsidered. This demand was refused by the board. The report had been officially sent to the Commissioner, and could not be recalled, or changed, if recalled, except by my consent.

However, to give Mr. Swineford an opportunity of pointing out alleged falsehoods I consented to a resolution (and without my consent the resolution could not have been passed) asking the Commissioner of Education to send the board a certified copy of the report, which was done.

The report itself was not recalled, but remained in Washington, and was printed as usual in the appendix of the annual report of the U. S. Commissioner of Education as the regular official report of schools in Alaska.

At a subsequent meeting of the board, January 23, 1889 (the general agent being absent), although a certified copy of my report had been received from Washington, it was neither read nor considered, but Judge Keatley was directed to make out a "new ́report and transmit the same to the Commissioner of Education."

This was not a substitute for the report of the general agent, as no one could legally make that report but himself. It was not even a report on education in Alaska, because Judge Keatley had recently come into the Territory and had no personal knowledge of its school affairs at that time. With his usual good judgment he did not attempt a report, but confined himself mainly to some general statements with regard to a few of the schools in southeastern Alaska, and particularly the training school at Sitka, of which he had some personal knowledge. His report was never submitted to the consideration of or approved by a vote of the Territorial board of education. In making his reflections upon the report of the general agent he was evidently misled by the assertions of Mr. Swineford, which were never proven, and I take this first opportunity since the publishing of the report of 1887-88 to deny that the report of the general agent for that year contains "a number of material inaccuracies."

Very truly yours,

SHELDON JACKSON, General Agent of Education for Alaska.

CHAPTER XXV.

CITY SCHOOL SYSTEMS.

A.-Remarks Relating to the Summary of City School Statistics and Supplementary Information-Differ ences in Local Organization-Reliability of School Statistics-Quantity of School Work Done in the City and in the Country Schools: The Proper Measure of School Work; Difference in the Quality of Work; Regularity of Attendance Greater in Cities; Number of Teachers and Their Salaries; Number and Value of Schoolhouses; Proportion of School Work Done by Cities (Table 1). B.-Remarks Relating to the Comparative Statistics, with Supplementary Information-Comparison of Statistics-Ratio of Total Enrollment to Population 6-14-Ratio of Aggregate Attendance to Popula tion 6-14-Private and Parochial Schools; Reasons for Large Private School Attendance-Proportion of Pupils in High Schools-What Proportion of the Pupils Receive High School Instruction-Comparison of Ratios for the Last Three Years (Table 2). C.-Remarks and Supplementary Information Suggested by the Tables of Detailed Statistics-Number of Supervising Officers-Whole Number of Persons Employed in Instruction-Average Salary of Teachers— Text-books; Location of Cities Employing the Free Text-book System (Table 3)-The Wealth of CitiesHigh Schools: Number of High Schools Compared with Population; Distribution by Geographical Divis ions of City Public High Schools (Table 4); Distribution by States of City Public High Schools (Table 5); Character of Instruction in High Schools; Sex of High School Graduates; Decreasing Proportion of Male Graduates; Number of Males and of Females Graduated from the High Schools of the Ten Largest Cities during 1860-64 Inclusive (Table 6); The Same during 1865-69 Inclusive (Table 7); The Same during 1885-89 Inclusive (Table 8)-Evening Schools: Falling off of Allendance; Unsatisfactory Condilion of Evening Schools; A More Definite Plan Needed; The Length of the Evening School Term— Public Kindergartens: Large Cities which have avowedly Established the Kindergarten System (Table 9); Cities which have Established one or more Kindergartens, Mainly Experimental (Table 10). D.-Remarks Relating to the Tables of Comparative Statistics of Individual Cities. E.-Statistical Tables: Summary by States, of Population 6-14, Enrollment, Attendance, Teachers, High Schools, Accommodations, School Property, and Cost of Tuition (Table 11)-Summary by States of Comparative Statistics of Enrollment, Attendance, Teachers, and Accommodations (Table 12)-Summary by States of Comparative Statistics of Property and Expenditures (Table 13)-Statistics of Population and School Attendance and Enrollment in Individual Cities (Table 14)-Statistics of Supervising Offi cers, Teachers, Salaries, and Accommodations (Table 15)-Statistics of Public High Schools (Table 16)— Statistics of Evening Schools (Table 17)-Statistics of Property and Receipts (Table 18)-Statistics of Expenditures (Table 19)-Comparative Statistics of Enrollment, Attendance, Teachers, and Accommodations (Table 20)-Comparative Statistics of Property and Expenditures (Table 21)-List of Cities and Villages Concerning which no Information is at Hand.

A-REMARKS RELATING TO THE SUMMARY OF STATISTICS OF CITY SCHOOLS (TABLE 11), AND INFORMATION SUPPLEMENTARY THERETO.

In the previous Reports of this Office it has been customary to include in the tables of summaries only those cities from which definite information was at hand. The table immediately following marks a departure from that method, in that it not only includes all the accurate data available, but also such estimates to supply deficiencies as may be regarded as reasonably reliable. The result desired is to secure a set of totals which will be totals in reality, and not the sum of results attained in a varying number of cities, leaving the rest unmentioned and unknown. The table is not without fault, but, inasmuch as all the cities are taken into account, it more nearly represents the sum of achievement of city schools than any similar table which has previously appeared.

The forthcoming federal census will probably show the number of cities and villages 'containing over 4,000 inhabitants to be somewhat greater or less than 768, the number included in the table, and if so, each item of the totals would be subject to correction. Numerous difficulties are experienced in perfecting the list of cities, and it may even now contain a few that do not possess the characteristics of cities to the extent necessary to their proper classification here, and it is equally true that some may have been omitted which have recently so grown and developed as to entitle them to be classified among urban communities.

765

DIFFERENCES IN LOCAL ORGANIZATION.

Such are the differences in local organization and government in the several States that the question of population is far from being the only perplexing element with which it is necessary to contend in this connection. Among the peculiarities which appear and which often involve problems of considerable difficulty may be mentioned

1. The village of Edgewater, N. Y., which has a population of about 10,000 in two independent, towns," is in three separate postal districts, not one of which bears the name of the village, and contains four school districts which have no direct connection with each other.

2. The cities of Florida, incorporated as cities, but whose schools are managed by county officers in the same way and upon the same basis as the adjacent rural schools. 3. Some Western cities, including Denver, Colo., which embrace three entirely independent school organizations among which the territory is divided.

4. A few Southern cities, notably Washington, D. C., which contain two full sets of school officers, working side by side, in the same field, but in behalf of different races. 5. Certain New England villages, which, though containing several thousand inhabitants and important business interests, have no legal status, save as parts of the "towns" in which they are situated. Many of these villages, unincorporated and amenable to the government of "town" or township officers, contain twice the population that would be expected in the South or the West to constitute a "city," with mayor and council, board of education, and all the other embellishments of a full grown municipality.

RELIABILITY OF SCHOOL STATISTICS.

Such anomalies as these, and they are many, necessarily involve such varying methods of recording and reporting school data that it is not reasonable to hope for a strictly accurate summary of the conditions of education in all places that may be properly considered in a general way as cities, even if all forwarded reports as nearly correct as the circumstances in each case would permit. But of the 768 cities reliable statistics of 713 or 92.8 per cent. of the entire number were secured and are incorporated in Tables 14 to 19. As will be seen from the Tables referred to, many of the cities failed to report some of the items-on an average each item was omitted by probably 10 per cent. of the cities. These omissions and failures to report amount, therefore, to over onesixth of the whole. This deficiency has been supplied by estimates based in each case upon the ratios developed by the surrounding cities or States.

In those cases in which no report was made of population excepting the estimated total, as in the cities of Pennsylvania and Minnesota, the population between six and fourteen was estimated by applying to the total population reported the ratio existing between the two at the last general census.

This explanation is given in order that the limitations to be placed upon the accuracy of the table may be fully known.

RELATIVE, QUANTITY OF SCHOOL WORK DONE IN THE CITY AND IN THE COUNTRY SCHOOLS.

A comparison of the facts developed by this table with the figures shown in the tables of school statistics of States in Chapter XXII of this Report shows the importance of the city school systems in the educational field in a very strong light.

THE PROPER MEASURE OF SCHOOL WORK.

The truest measure of the quantity of work done is not the number of pupils enrolled, for that number may include those whose stay in school was too short to produce any tangible result; nor the average attendance, for that gives no idea of the time attended; nor the length of the school term, for that furnishes no clue to the number of children. The only quantity that takes all these things into consideration is what is technically called the "aggregate, or total attendance," which is determined by simply adding together the number of days every pupil was present in school. The result is the total number of days attended by all pupils, and may be said to be a measure of the total amount of instruction given.

Taking this item as the basis of comparison, it appears that 35.3 per cent., consider ably over one-third, of all the instruction reported in public schools in the United States is given in cities, since the aggregate number of days' attendance on the part of all public school pupils in the entire country was 1,076,613,716, and the corresponding quantity for the cities alone was 379,800,612.

T

This, taken in connection with the fact that only 26.2 per cent. of the population 6 to 14, and only 22.6 per cent. of the whole enrollment are reported in the cities, shows the result of the more regular attendance and the longer school terms in the cities.

DIFFERENCE IN THE QUALITY OF WORK.

Let it be remembered that this estimate takes into consideration only the quantity of work done. A day in a "backwoods" country school is placed upon the same footing with a day in the finest school in the country. It does not, nor can it, introduce the question of quality of instruction in any way whatever. There can be little doubt that the portion of the nation's school work which the city systems do would be proved to be not far from one-half of the whole if it were possible to show on one hand the loss of time in so many rural schools by reason of frequent changes of teachers and methods of instruction, misdirected efforts and fruitless work resulting from inexperience or incompetence, lack of proper equipment and helps to teaching; and on the other hand, the advantages which accrue to the schools of the cities from close organization, skillful supervision, consultation of teachers, more or less permanent tenure of office, good houses and a fairly abundant quantity of supplies and apparatus that go far toward smoothing the rough road of instruction.

REGULARITY OF ATTENDANCE GREATER IN CITIES.

As stated above, the attendance of children enrolled is far more regular in cities than in country schools, the ratio being 71.4 per cent. in cities and 65.1 per cent. in the United States as a whole. This difference will probably never be overcome, for it is impossible in the country to reach the city standard of accessibility of schoolhouses, even if the teaching were as attractive and the buildings themselves were as favorable to regular attendance. In the matter of length of term there is more reason to hope for improvement, for in some States there is now very little difference between the city and the country schools in this respect. At present the average length of the school year is 191.6 days in the cities alone and 134.5 days in the entire country at large.

NUMBER OF TEACHERS AND THEIR SALARIES.

Only about one-seventh of the whole number of teachers in the United States are employed in city schools, but of the amount expended for teaching and supervision, 36.1 per cent. is paid by the cities. Except the showing of the approximately exact figures, nothing new is developed by this, for it is self-evident that large graded schools require a relatively small number of teachers; and it has been a matter of general regret since the inception of the public-school system that the wages paid country school-teachers are pitifully small. The greater length of the school term is also a factor which materially increases the proportion paid to city teachers.

There is very little difference in the average cost of tuition for each day's attendance of a pupil in the city and in the country, being 8.3 cents in one case and about 8.1 cents in the other. This near approach to equality is due solely to the low salaries paid in the country. If country teachers were paid at the same rate per diem as city teachers, owing to the proportionally greater number required, the average cost of one day's instruction for one pupil in the country would be about 15.9 cents, or almost twice as much as in the cities.

NUMBER AND VALUE OF SCHOOLHOUSES.

There are 216,330 schoolhouses in the United States, and only 7,670, or 3.5 per cent, of them, are in the cities-another instance of the economy possible in a dense population. In the United States, exclusive of cities, there is an average of one building to every 43 persons between 6 and 14 years of age, or one to every 29 pupils in average daily attendance in school, while in the cities the average is only one building to every 415 persons. between 6 and 14, or to every 258 persons in average attendance.

The value of school property in the cities amounts to 52.8 per cent. of the whole. In other words, 7,670 buildings with their sites and furnishings are more valuable than all the remaining 208,660 houses with their grounds and equipments. Of course this is due principally to the great superiority of the city buildings in size, quality, and furnishing, but the great difference between land values in urban and rural localities affects the ratio, although it would be impossible to definitely determine to what extent. The average value of each building, including site, furniture, etc., in the entire United States is $1,495; in the cities it is $25,583.