ページの画像
PDF
ePub
[blocks in formation]

words heavenly and heaven, which occur in the 12th verse, and in the first clause of the 13th, metaphorically, as signifying the sublime or mysterious doctrines of religion, but drop the figure when they come to the second and third clause of the 13th verse, and represent our Saviour as asserting that he as the son of man left heaven, his state of glory, and was, at the same time, as the son of man, in that state of glory. But surely an interpretation leading to such an absurd conclusion may well be pronounced inconsistent both with itself, and with the dogma which it professes to illustrate-as well as in direct opposition to the spirit, and even to the letter, of the passage. The meaning of verse 13th is probably as follows: "No man is so well instructed in the character and designs of God, as Jesus of Nazareth, who was appointed to be the Revealer of the Divine will, and who, being abundantly endowed with the holy spirit, was eminently qualified for executing his glorious commission."

To confirm our exposition of the passage we have been discussing, it may justly be remarked, that if the phrase "who is in heaven" affords sufficient evidence for the omnipresence of Christ, similar expressions applied in Scripture to the primitive Christians" will, on the same principle of interpretation, equally establish the omnipresence of his disciples!

4. No mention is here made of the ubiquity either of Christ or of God. Jesus evidently meant to promise, that with his disciples only—with those who obeyed his commands-should he and his Father make their abode. The sentiment, though figurative, is replete with love and truth; but is as little favourable to the doctrine of Christ's omnipresence, as other expressions of a similar import, in the same discourse, and in his intercessory prayer, are to the omnipresence of the disciples. Jesus not only spoke of being with his followers, and of residing with them, but sometimes varied his language by the employment of such phrases as being in them, dwelling in them, and THEY IN HIM." According to the Trinitarian principle of interpreting Scripture, these words will prove, that Christians exist in every part of space; for if Jesus be omnipresent, and his followers dwell in him, then must they be where he is,—namely, everywhere.

5. This text is considered by few respectable writers of the Trinitarian persuasion as affording any support to the doctrine of the omnipresence of our Lord. But as it is sometimes prominently exhibited, in an insulated state, in tracts designed for popular use, we may be allowed to present it, with others of a similar kind, to show the utter invalidity of the argument built thereon. It is evident, that St. Paul means only to represent Jesus as the head of the Christian church, to which he was appointed by God, and which, in the apostolic age, was supplied by him with miraculous gifts from the Father for the diffusion of Gospel truth.P

SECT. IX.-EXAMINATION OF THE SCRIPTURE EVIDENCE ALLEGED FOR THE OPINION, THAT CHRIST IS OMNISCIENT.

ALLEGED PROOFS.

1. John ii. 24, 25: But Jesus did not commit himself unto them, because he knew all [men,] and needed not that any should testify of man; for he knew what was in man. because he knew [them] all.-Bible 1613, Le Clerc, Campbell. he knew all [of them].-Imp. Ver. all knew him.-Wakefield. (See p. 273.)

2. See Matt. ix. 4; xii. 25. Luke vi. 8; ix. 47; xi. 17. John i. 47-50; iv. 17, 18; vi. 61, 64; x. 14. With Parallel Passages.

[blocks in formation]

REMARKS.

If this be not a direct and unqualified claim of a peculiar divine prerogative, there is no meaning in human language.

The terms in which he expresses himself .. evidently proceed upon the express assumption, that this [the searching of the heart] is the exclusive preroga tive of ONE BEING only.-Wardlaw.

His [Dr. Wardlaw's] argument proceeds from inattention to the following circumstances. The want of the present tense in Hebrew verbs is supplied by the participle, following the pronoun, agreeing with it in number and person, and having sometimes the definite article prefixed. From the Hebrew this construction has been transferred into the Greek of the Septuagint and of the New Testament. For example, the expression, “I am he that came (it should be, cometh) out of the army,” (Εγώ ειμι ὁ ηκων εκ της παρεμβολης, 1 Sam. iv. 16,) means only, "I come out of the army." In like manner, "I am he that searcheth" (Eyw us & egenväv) signifies nothing more than "I search" (Eya guv). -Yates.

a

ILLUSTRATIVE TEXTS.

King David is said to have known all things in the earth.-2 Sam. xiv. 20.

Ahijah knew the thoughts of Jeroboam's wife. 1 Kings xiv. 5, 6.

By supernatural knowledge Elisha detected the avarice and falsehood of his servant Gehazi.-2 Kings v. 25, 26.

Elisha knew, by inspiration, the words uttered by the Syrian king in his bed-chamber.—2 Kings vi. 12. The same prophet perceived beforehand the wicked dispositions and conduct of Hazael.-2 Kings viii. 11, 12.

Daniel knew the thoughts of Nebuchadnezzar.— Dan. ii. 23, 28, 29.

Peter was acquainted with the hearts of Ananias and Sapphira.- Acts v. 3, 4; 8, 9.

The apostles possessed the gift of the discerning of spirits.-1 Cor. xii. 10.

[blocks in formation]

f Ps. xciv. 9: He that planted the ear, shall he not hear? He that formed the eye, shall he not see? Prov. xv. 3: The eyes of Jehovah [are] in every place, beholding the evil and the good. Isa. xl. Jehovah, or, [being] his counsellor, hath 13, 14: Who hath directed the spirit of taught him? With whom took he counsel, and [who] instructed him, and taught him in the path of judgment? &c. - See Ps. cxxxix. 1-4; cxlvii. 5.

9 John vii. 16: My doctrine is not mine, but His that sent me. Chap. viii. 28: As my Father hath taught me, I speak these things. Acts x. 38: God anointed Jesus of Nazareth with the holy spirit and with power, &c.-See John iii. 34, 35.

h Rev. i. 1: The revelation of Jesus Christ, which God gave unto him, &c.

i Rev. ii. 26, 27: And he that overcometh, to him will I give power over the nations, .. even as 1 received of my Father.

..

SECT. IX.-EXAMINATION OF THE SCRIPTURE EVIDENCE ALLEGED FOR THE OPINION, THAT CHRIST IS OMNISCIENT.

OBSERVATIONS.

1, 2. That Jesus possessed an intimate acquaintance with the human heart,a deep, a supernatural insight into human character, cannot be questioned by any one who admits the divine origin of Christianity. The inquiry, then, will be, Whether a knowledge of the dispositions and thoughts of men can be imparted by God to created beings? Whether such knowledge was received by our Lord? or, Whether it belonged to him as an original, underived, inherent right? In answer to the first interrogatory, it may briefly be replied, that, as we learn from Scripture, the Almighty did actually bestow this gift on prophets and apostles;" and, accordingly, it was a common opinion, in our Saviour's time, that divinely-inspired teachers were endowed with the power of scrutinizing the hearts of men. With respect to the other questions, the reader is requested to turn, for a reply, to a former portion of this work, in which he will find the clearest and the most copious evidence for the Unitarian doctrine, that Christ derived all his knowledge from the Fountain of intelligence-from the Creator and Governor of the universe.

3. Trinitarians put forth this text in a very prominent point of view, by comparing it with some passages which announce Jehovah as the only Being who searcheth the reins and hearts. The phraseology here adopted by our Lord is undoubtedly similar to that which was employed by God himself; but all arguments derived from the use of such language are obviously inconclusive, unless it imply the existence of attributes not belonging to created beings; which in this case it does not imply, as we have already shown from the power which prophets and apostles had of searching the hearts of men.e The great and essential difference, as respects the knowledge possessed by God and by Christ, consists in the circumstance, that the former was not indebted to any source whatever for this perfection of his nature, but the latter derived his extraordinary acquaintance with the human heart from that Being whose Son and Messenger he was. The language contained in the Scriptures concerning God, intimates that his wisdom and knowledge are underived and illimitable: that which is used of Christ, in many portions of the New Testament, is of such a nature as can be applied only to one whose knowledge was restricted to particular subjects, and who obtained from a Superior Intelligence all the wisdom of which he was in possession. The book of Apocalypse itself furnishes the most satisfactory evidence, that our Master, even in his exalted state, is inferior to the Father, and that he received from God the revelation which he communicated to his servants," and the power which he was enabled to impart to them.'

EE

ALLEGED PROOFS.

4. John vi. 46: Not that any man hath seen the Father, save he who is of God, he hath seen the Father. is from God.-Campbell, Wakefield, Smith, Imp. Ver. à Deo.-Calvin, Beza, Tremellius, Piscator.

PARAPHRASE.

When I speak of men's hearing and learning of God, I do not mean that they can see God personally, and be taught of him in the manner that a scholar is taught of his master. No man hath seen the Father personally, except the Son, whom the Father hath sent, and whose peculiar privilege it is to have been taught immediately of the Father, the doctrine which he preaches to men.-Macknight.

REMARKS.

The word wgaxɛ here does not mean to see with bodily eyes, but with the mental eye, i. e. to know. What but omniscience could be adequate to the knowledge here predicated of Christ?―Stuart.

Other persons were instructed by the doctrine and miracles of inspired men; but Jesus, by personal intercourse with the Deity.-Kenrick.

Save he, &c.] The pure in heart. See Matt. v. 8. Heb. xii. 14.-Wakefield.

See Appendix, page 273, second column.

5. John x. 14, 15: I am the good shepherd, and know my [sheep], and am known of mine. As the Father knoweth me, even so know I the Father; and I lay down my life for the sheep.-See Matt. xi. 27. I am the good shepherd; and know my [sheep], and am known of mine, as the Father knoweth me, and I know the Father, &c.-Griesbach: whose punctuation is similar to that adopted by Hammond, S. Clarke, Le Clerc, Campbell, Macknight, and others.

REMARKS.

The Father's knowledge of the Son is as intimate and perfect, as it is unrestrained and unrestrainable. So also is the Son's knowledge of the Father. Therefore there is not any thing in the whole realm of space, whether it be mind or matter, which can be concealed from the knowledge of the Son of God.Orthodox Presbyterian, Aug. 1830.

There is a like expression, 1 Cor. xiii. 12, "Then shall I know, even as also I am known;" and in 1 John iii. 2, "We shall see him as he is."- S. Clarke.

For Dr. Hammond's paraphrase, see p. 273.

ILLUSTRATIVE TEXTS.

j Ver. 27-63: Labour not for the meat which perisheth, but for that meat which endureth unto everlasting life, which the Son of man shall give unto you, &c.

k Ver. 45, 46: It is written in the prophets, And they shall be all taught of God. Every man that hath heard and hath learned of the Father, cometh unto me. Not that any man hath seen the Father, save he who is of God; he hath seen the Father. (G.)-Comp. chap. xiv. 6—11.

1 Ver. 36: But I said unto you, that ye also have seen me, and believe not. Ver. 40: For this is the will of Him that sent me, that every one who seeth the Son, and believeth on him, may have everlasting life; and I will raise him up at the last day. (G.)

To see the Son; to see the character and mission of the Son.-Macknight. to understand the doctrine of Christ.-Eds. of Imp. Ver.

m 1 John iii. 6: Whosoever sinneth hath not seen him [Christ], neither known him. 3 John, 11: He that doeth good is of God; he that doeth evil hath not seen God. (G.)

n John x. 3, 4: The sheep hear his voice; and he calleth his own sheep by name, and leadeth them out. And when he putteth forth his own sheep, he goeth before them; and the sheep follow him, for they know his voice.

o (See different translation in corresponding column.)

p John x. 14: I.. know my [sheep], and am known of mine. 1 John ii. 3: Hereby we do know that we know him, if we keep his commandments. See John xvii. 3.

q John xvii. 25, 26: O righteous Father, the world hath not known thee; but I have known thee, and these have known that thou hast sent me. And I have declared unto them thy name, and will declare [it]; that the love wherewith thou hast loved me may be in them, and I in them. 1 John ii. 13: I write unto you, little children, because ye have known the Father. Chap. iv. 7: Beloved, let us love one another; for love is of God, and every one that loveth is born of God, and knoweth God. See Matt. xi. 27.

OBSERVATIONS.

4. The whole discourse in which these words occur are of a highly figurative nature. Christ had been speaking to the Jews of persons who had been taught by God, and had heard and learned of the Father;* by which he could have meant only, that men were instructed in the will of the Deity. But as Jesus possessed higher and more correct notions of God's character and designs, having been invested with a divine commission superior to that of all former prophets, he, with great propriety, continued the beautiful figure, by adding, that though others had heard and learned of God, they had not seen him—they had not become acquainted with the more profound secrets of religion; he alone having been blessed with this invaluable privilege. The phrase seeing the Father seems to be analogous to seeing the Son-an expression which is twice used in the same discourse,' and which, in all probability, signifies acquainted with the divine mission of Christ, or understanding his doctrines. The Apostle John, who was the reporter of these discourses, does not seem to have had the faintest idea of their containing any allusion to the omniscience of his beloved Master; since, in his Epistles, he employs the phrases, not seeing Christ, not seeing God, in reference to wicked persons; implying evidently that good men have seen Christ, and have seen God-have possessed a practical knowledge of the character and will of their heavenly Father, as revealed by his Son Jesus Christ.

m

[ocr errors]

5. From these words Trinitarians infer the omniscience of our Saviour; but, sure we are, they cannot assign any good reason for such an inference. Jesus, through the medium of allegory, had been discoursing of the love and affection which subsisted between him and his true disciples ;" and to us it appears obvious, that, by comparing the moral intimacy which subsisted between himself and the Father of all, he meant only to express, in powerful terms, the fervent love which he bore towards his faithful followers, and their deep-rooted attachment to his person and his religion. But whatever be the signification of the passage, the argument of the Trinitarian is flimsy and inconclusive; for, if adopted, it would lead to results at war with the plainest dictates of common sense. What is the proof deduced for the Deity of Christ?. The Father, who is omniscient, knoweth the Son; the Son knoweth the Father: therefore the Son is omniscient. Well: The Son who is omniscient, knoweth his disciples, and they know him; therefore, they are omniscient! A similar observation may be made respecting the argument for the omniscience of Christ drawn from Matt. xi. 27. If, according to Dr. DWIGHT, "he who knows the Father is omniscient," it will evidently follow, that all true Christians-who, as such, must have received from their Master a knowledge of the Father?-are actually in possession of an attribute which belongs exclusively to the Divine Being!

« 前へ次へ »