and in their progress through the Hebrides, rouse to action the martial chiefs and population of the west. Arrived at Brodick-bay, in Arran, the Bruce is joined by Douglas, Boyd, Lennox, De La Haye, &c. and their unshrinking soldiery. The king here visits his sister, who, we are surprised to find, is residing in the convent of St. Bride; the dumb boy, accompanies him as the future attendant upon the princess; and the Bruce performs his promise to Ronald of pleading his suit with Isobel. Isobel in answer, and in the presence of her new page, earnestly assures her brother of her determination not to listen to the vows of her lover, until he lays at her feet, "The ring which bound the faith he swore, By Edith freely yielded o'er," and an acquittal from his engagement with that lovely wanderer, "By her who brooks his perjur'd scorn." Robert departs, and the Canto concludes with his resolution immediately to attempt the recovery of his patrimonial castle and demesne of Carrick from Clifford its English and usurping tenant. Canto the fifth discovers Isobel performing her matin devotions in the cloister of St. Bride. Rising from her orisons, she perceives on the floor of her cell, a packet, addressed to herself. She opens it-it contains a ring, and a resignment by Edith of all her claims upon Ronald. Her astonishment is increased when upon inquiry whether any stranger has been admitted into the nunnery since the visit of the Bruce, the portress replies in the negative, but informs her that the dumb page has flown! Is the mystery unravelled?-Was it Edith herself?-The princess instantly despatches a messenger to the army to seek the page. The messenger, a monk, finds that the page has been despatched by the prince to the opposite shore, to agree with the friends of the king upon signals for the attack upon Carrick. The fleet sets sail, steering towards the flaming beacon, kindled by the patriots on the Carrick shore. The picturesque effect of the illumination on the woody promontories and jutting rocks, is very vividly described. 'They proceed with hope, but the fierce and broad spreading of the flame, and its sudden extinction, raise doubts in all but Edward of its human origin. They land -the dumb stripling joins them, bringing a letter from an adherent of the Bruce, informing him that the English are in force at Carrick, that Lorn and his rebels have just joined the band of Clifford, aħd confirming their apprehensions concerning the mysterious and alarming beacon. Daunted for a moment by these discouraging tidings, the never-desponding prince revives their spirits, "hap what may, In Carrick Carrick's lord must stay;" and with renovated ardour they proceed to take up a position in the vicinity of the fortress, there to concert the best plan of storming the place. The page accompanies their march, cheered and supported by Ronald; but the stripling's strength proving unequal to the rapid and toilsome progress over the rough and broken ground, he is left behind in the hollow of a large oak, where he is discovered by a reconnoitering party of the English garrison. Dragged before Clifford and Lorn, and refusing to answer their questions, they order him to immediate death. At the place of execution, the prayers and funeral lament for the victim reach the royal party, which is stationed in ambush in the vicinity. Ronald burns for the instant attack-the king assures the impatient warrior that "they shall not harm, A ringlet of the stripling's hair," but desires him to wait till the troops have been disposed so as to cut off all communication between the garrison and the detachment encircling the captive. To Edward is assigned the task of securing the drawbridge of the castle, and to Douglas that of intercepting the fugitives. The signal for the assault, a spear raised by the latter over the copse of his appointed station, is speedily given by the valiant earl. The strife begins-the page is rescued-and the enemy annihilated. At the same moment the prince attacks and secures the fortress-Clifford is slain Lorn escapes-and Carrick is once more in possession of its rightful owner. Canto the sixth. Isobel has taken the vows in St. Bride's convent. The dumb page, now confessedly the maid of Lorn, at least to the princess, has been sent to the convent for his, or we should rather say her, personal safety. The glorious achievements and triumphs of the Bruce during the seven succeeding years, are then recorded in about ten verses, and we pounce on the mutual preparations for the decisive conflict of Bannockbourn. Here the immediate thread of the narrative is broken, to inform us of Edith's departure for the royal camp in her former disguise, to convince herself of the re newed affection of the faithful Lord of the Isles for the fair object of his early and ardent adoration-that gallant and prudent chief, easily foregoing his love for Isobel on her taking the veil, and with a praiseworthy attention to his worldly affairs, resuming his suit to Edith upon discovering the king's intention of conferring upon the Maid of Lorn the confiscated lands of her rebellious brother. She arrives at the camp the evening before the battle, and reveals her sex and name to the king. The Bruce assures her of his tenderest friendship, and places her on an eminence in the rear of the army, with the attendants of the camp. Then follows the battle, in the description of which, though little varied from the chronicles of the times, there is a glow and animation which render it inferior only to the admirable stanzas in which Mr. Scott has immortalized the defeat of his counby men at Flodden. At the close of the combat, Edith, still disguised as the page, and alarmed at the danger of her lover, forgets her dissembled dumbness, and passionately calls upon the retainers of the camp to marshal themselves in military show, and bear down to the assistance of the army. They obey with shouts of rapture the call which appears to them the miraculous interposition of heaven in favour of Scotland; and the English host, deeming them to be fresh troops advancing to succour the Bruce, is seized with a confusion and panic, and borne down and vanquished on every side. The poem terminates with the king's order to make princely preparations for the nuptials of Edith with the Lord of the Isles (whose pardon for his amorous perjury he has secured from the Maid of Lorn,) to be celebrated at the abbey of Cambuskenneth immediately after the mass for the victory of Bannockbourn. Such is the story of the Lord of the Isles; and the reader, if he has had patience to read the whole of our examen, must, we think, have gathered sufficient evidence of the impropriety of the title, and felt that the dignity of the main subject, is much injured by the paltry underplot attached to it. In a poem where Robert, the Bruce, appears, how is it possible that we should interest ourselves in the adventures of so insignificant a person as Ronald. But this is not the only defect. There are several contradictions, of history-character-and of the poet by himself. Of history, a striking one occurs in the capture of Carrick, which did not take place for some years after the time men tioned; an attack was made, it is true, and a considerable advantage gained by the Bruce on his return from Ireland, not, however, against Clifford, but earl Percy. Clifford was in the action, under Percy, but was not slain; he fell at Bannockbourn. Of the contradictions of character it will be sufficient to bring forward one in that of the Bruce. Unquestionably, that heroic monarch was of a temper never surpassed for humanity, munificence, and nobleness; yet to represent him sorrowing over the death of the First Plantagenet-after the repeated and tremendous ills inflicted by him on Scotland-the patriot Wallace murdered by his order, as well as the royal race of Wales; and the brothers of the Bruce slaughtered by his command-to represent, we repeat, the just and generous Robert, feeling an instant's compassion for the death of such a man, is, in a Scottish poet, so unnatural a violation of truth and decency, not to say patriotism, that we are really astonished that the author could have conceived the idea, much more that he could suffer his pen to record it. This abasement on the part of the Bruce is farther heightened by the king's half reprehension of the prince's stern and noble expression of undying hatred against his country's spoiler and family's assassin. Mr. Scott, we have said, contradicts himself. How will he reconcile the following facts to the satisfaction of his readers? The third canto informs us that Isobel accompanies Edward to Ireland, there to remain till the termination of the war; and in the fourth, the second day after her departure, we discover the princess counting her beads, and reading homilies in the cloister of St. Bride. Of the characters, prince Edward is, most decidedly, our favourite. Of unshaken resolution, a valour reckless of al! danger, romantic and ardent, we always find him at the post of peril, heedless of opposition, and beating down resistance. Of matchless activity, and burning to distinguish himself, in action, in council, Edward is ever the first to advise, to perform. The Bruce, according to our notions of a hero, is a good deal too calm,too willing to think and say polite things of his adversary,-too ready to reprehend the fine effusions of his brother's generous spirit. Mr. Scott has aimed at contrast by investing the king with a dignity of mind and language superior to that of the prince, but we cannot think he has been altogether successful, for surely the chict quality of a hero is the energy which over comes all obstacle. Now, of this quality Edward indisputably possesses a greater degree than his wiser brother, and we frequently feel that the sage preparation and frigid manoeuvring of the Bruce would fail altogether where the unhesitating impetuosity of Edward would command success. Ronald is an abortion. Lorn is admirably sketched, and the character of Torquil of Dunvegan-his blunt integrity, substantial patriotism, and rugged magnanimity-all bodied forth in a sort of wildly-poetical speech, very much to the purpose, however-constitute this Hebridean chief a most interesting original in his way. We were surprised not to find him in the battle. It is not irrelevant to remark, by the way, that in his narrative of the conflict of Bannockbourn, Mr. Scott seems more anxious to blazon the pomp and valour of his country's ravagers, than to paint the conquering heroism of the Bruce and his chieftains. For one Scottish name of distinction, we find at least half a dozen English; and the fall of De Argentine, a brave English knight, is adorned with more circumstances of splendour than the deeds of the Bruce himself. Of the ladies Isobel and Edith, little have we to say, for little is it they do. Isobel evidently takes the veil merely out of good-nature to the maid of Lorn, who, notwithstanding the prudential fickleness of Ronald, cherishes a most disheartening attachment to the recreant. The story of the dumb page, though occasionally giving birth to situations of interest, is, upon the whole, a mawkish contrivance-a new dressing up of a very old trick. In her character of page, Edith performs nothing that would not have been better executed by any stout lad. The share these ladies possess in the poem, consists principally in tedious and oppressive conversations about their mutual mishaps, and it must be confessed that they do keep up the shuttlecock of chit-chat with a perseverance exceeding ly honourable to the daughters of Eve. The most pleasing and natural character in the Lord of the Isles (Allan, the page of Ronald,) we just get a glimpse of, only to see him murdered before our eyes, for no earthly reason that will abide a mo ment's examination. The poor boy should not have had the task of watching imposed upon his tender years. That was the business of robuster frames, and should have been divided between the Bruce and his master. Examples of forced and uncouth diction are frequent; and there is introduced a very respectable quantity of obsolete terms, which our grandfathers had very XXX. A power that will not be repress'd. Again that light has fired his eye, "Merrily, merrily, bounds the bark She bounds before the gale, With fluttering sound like laughter hoarse, The waves, divided by her force, And Slapin's cavern'd shore. Thick wreaths of eddying smoke were spread; And, ready at the sight, Mac-Kinnon's chief, in warfare gray, Signal of Ronald's high command, His cur's wild clamour he shall chide, His varied plaid display; To yonder turret gray. And oft when moon on ocean slept, That lovely lady sate and wept Upon the castle-wall, And turn'd her eye to southern climes, And sounds, as of a captive lone, The murmur of a lute, The tribute of a sigh! And gave his pastime o'er, The bones which strew that cavern's gloom, Merrily, merrily, goes the bark On a breeze from the northward free, So shoots through the morning sky the lark. Or the swan through the summer sea. The shores of Mull on the eastward lay, And Ulva dark and Colonsay, And all the group of islets gay That guard famed Staffa round. The cormorant had found," Nor doth its entrance front in vain To old Iona's holy fane, That nature's voice might seem to say, Merrily, merrily, goes the bark, Before the gale she bounds; So darts the dolphin from the shark, And they waken'd the men of the wild Tiree, Lord Ronald's call obey, And Scarba's isles, whose tortured shore And lonely Colonsay; -Scenes sung by him who sings no more! His bright and brief career is o'er, And mute his tuneful strains! Has LEYDEN's cold remains! Ever the breeze blows merrily, They held unwonted way;- Upon the eastern bay. O'er Kilmaconnel moss, Now launch'd once more, the inland sea And steer for Arran's isle; And bade Loch-Ranza smile. Each puny wave in diamonds roll'd O'er the calm deep, where hues of gold The hill, the vale, the tree, the tower, With breathless pause between. O who, with speech of war and woes, Would wish to break the soft repose Of such enchanting scene!" The setting forth of the Bruce and his followers for the attack of Carrick Castle, and the appearance of the supernatural beacon, are related with extraordinary vividness and effect. XII. "Now on the darkening main afloat, 'O Heaven! when swords for freedom shine, In night the fairy prospects sink, The black-cock deem'd it day, and crew. Like some tall castle given to flame, VOL. III.-No, rv. 36 |